Skip to main contentSkip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.
Ed Perkins on Travel: Honest hotel prices: A small win

Ed Perkins on Travel: Honest hotel prices: A small win

  • 0


Consumers enjoyed what is at least a small win last week. In response to a petition brought by the Pennsylvania attorney general, Marriott International agreed not to misrepresent room rates, mandatory fees, or total price in its advertising. Basically, Marriott agreed not to engage in deceptively featuring low-ball room rates, with mandatory fees added later. Although this agreement at least nudges a major hotel away from an ongoing deceptive practice, its effect on the widespread industry practice is yet to be determined — and will likely be small.

The Issue. The key issue here is a deception practiced by thousands of hotels, especially in the U.S. and nearby vacation destinations. Instead of posting the real price of a room from the outset, they carve out a portion of the rate as a "resort" or other mandatory fee and post the remainder as the "base rate," both on their own websites and on the rates they give to online travel agents (OTA) such as and metasearch systems such as Kayak.

The Deception. Many travelers see only these low-ball pre-fee figures when they compare hotel prices. Regardless of channel, the fees are added back before the final purchase, so hotels can claim they aren't "hidden." But they are hidden during an initial rate search, and they're often hidden in other advertising. The Big OTAs and metasearch systems are pretty good about adding small-print notifications pretty early about fees to be paid later, but other advertisers do not. For example, I regularly receive promotional emails from tour packagers promoting spectacular hotel "deals" such as Las Vegas for $17 a night, with no footnote or other indication that after the mandatory fee, the real price is $38, not $17.

This practice is clearly deceptive. It is designed to be deceptive — to lead consumers into choosing a more expensive hotel than they might otherwise have chosen. The Federal Trade Commission has specifically identified it as deceptive, and sent out a letter saying so. But beyond that letter, and despite its mandate to protect the public from deceptive advertising, the FTC has done nothing further to stop the deception.

What the Agreement Does. Marriott promises to display all-up fee-inclusive rates most prominently on its websites and other price promotions. Specifically, price searches on Marriott websites will be based on total; price, inclusive of mandatory fees. The agreement applies to all owned, franchised or other Marriott affiliates. The agreement also calls for Marriott to provide all relevant information in the rates it submits to affiliated OTAs and metasearch systems. That's certainly a plus.

What the Agreement Lacks. Unfortunately, the agreement contains two big gaps in consumer protection where the agreement fails:

• It legitimizes the false claims that the mandatory fees apply to specific services. And that's not true: Hotels traditionally list services the fees supposedly cover: swimming pool, gym, Wi-Fi, and such. But as long as a fee is mandatory, what the hotel says it covers is meaningless. Sadly, the agreement appears to accept and legitimize this fiction.

• It places no obligation on third-parties such as OTAs and metasearch systems to display only Marriott's full, fee-inclusive rates. Marriott may provide those rates, but Marriott won't require third parties use to show only honest all-up rates in their own comparisons. To anyone using a non-Marriott search system for rate comparisons, as far as I can see, it will remain "business as usual" and therefore "deception as usual" comparisons.

What's Next. To me, the key to getting rid of the deception is third-party compliance. Instead of going after additional hotel chains, I would hope that the attorneys general looking at the problem next target a big OTA or metasearch system. I've been personally surprised that other than just the single system, Kayak, no big system has promoted "honest hotel price comparisons." To me, that should be a winner. But apparently the bigger guys might need a legal kick in the butt finally to "do the right thing." Consumers got a win, but it ain't over yet.

(Send e-mail to Ed Perkins at Also, check out Ed’s new rail travel website at

Need to get away?

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

Bye, bye, bikini. Hello, parka!

When the weather turns chilly, travelers run in the direction of sun, sand, and sandals. But there are some beaches in the world where it’s hardly beach weather in winters. Quite the opposite, in fact. From the Jersey Shore to the Baltic coast, snow falling on beaches is an incredible, magical sight. White, powdery snow covers sandy beaches and turns the scenery into a winter wonderland unlike any you may have seen. Here we have 11 beaches where snow makes an appearance, so pack your beanies and gloves because things can get pretty cold out there.

From watermelon-shaped water towers to a replica of the leaning tower of Pisa.

America is a land full of wonders. With the Statue of Liberty, Mount Rushmore, Golden Gate Bridge, and brick walls painted with angel wings or the word “Love”—we’re spoiled rotten, aren’t we, Augustus Gloop? And just when we thought we were gagged with IG gold, here comes another one to tickle the tonsils. Wait for it…water tanks.  “Water tanks? Those big ugly cylinders out on the freeway? Fodor’s, you can’t be serious?” We imagine you saying behind your laptop screen. Well, things have gotten pretty serious, so much so that there are annual tank awards honoring the most creative uses of water tank coatings in North America. They’re more prestigious than the Golden Globes right now, dahling. Not convinced? Scroll down and enjoy.

Usher in the Year of the Tiger with these traditions hailing from Vietnam to Malaysia.

Chinese New Year is possibly considered the most significant and important festival on the Lunar Calendar. This year, the Year of the Tiger, officially begins on February 1 and so marks many traditions and cultural activities Asian families must adhere to in the lead-up to the big day. Lucky foods must be cooked and eaten, a visit to the temple to honor those no longer with us is mandatory, and cleaning the house is imperative to remove any evil spirits and bad energy for a fresh start to a new year. With millions of Chinese migrants around the world, the Lunar New Year is not restricted to just the walls of China but has expanded all across Asia. Each country, region, and even sub-regional communities have their own traditions, showing the diversity of the Asian diaspora. My childhood involved a visit to the temple with my aunty and uncle, as well as going shopping with my mom for new clothes, but my friends in Vietnam, Singapore, and Malaysia have other family traditions I didn’t even know existed, which I love hearing about. Here are a few of my favorite Lunar New Year traditions that you too can incorporate into your new year celebrations. 新年快樂! Happy New Year!

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.